
This film was fairly well put together from a thematic standpoint. The main thread focusses on the concept of "minimalism", overconsumption and materialism in then modern age. It goes about discussing the lifestyle and it's ramifications through personal stories and anecdotes from a variety of attractive middle class Americans, most of whom have come from wealthy, materialistic backgrounds before finding a level of solace in a much more reductionist way of living. Most of their arguments hold up pretty well, and I find it difficult to criticise their reasoning for choosing such a path. Indeed, who wouldn't be happy to live such a life? The through line of the whole thing is the story of The Minimalists, a pair of men in their early 30's (I think) who abandoned their six figure salary corporate jobs to become full time advocates for this lifestyle, authoring books and touring the country promoting it. Most of the interviews were engaging if a little void of original content. The stuff I enjoyed the most was when it covered the severe environmental and social consequences of a culture that relies so heavily on material wealth. They used the poignant example of the fashion industry, citing things like the built in obsolescence of clothes based on trends. It became clear to me that this is simply not compatible with any form of sustainability and eventually we will not be able to keep it up forever.
The film also comments on the psychology of materialism, interviewing the likes of Sam Harris and other experts on the subject. This was interesting and for the most part, but it quite literally only scratches the surface of something that seems scarily close to the very core of our nature. Nonetheless, I still think it was a necessary part of the film because it provided the context for why we might want to think more about living simpler lives.
One assumption the film makes a little bit too readily is that owning lots of stuff or making a lot of money does not make people happy. Often we hear people saying things like "I looked at the people around me making a lot of money and I could see that they weren't happy". Well how do you know they aren't happy? Did you ask them? This brings me to my biggest criticism of this film, that it ascribes a belief system about happiness onto everybody, rarely taking into account the individuality of preference that we know exists in all of society. I am sure there are millionaires out there living in mansions who are very happy indeed, just as I am sure there are those who are not. The more interesting question is whether materialism is a more generalised problem for ordinary people, and if so why and who does it affect the most? Although the film makes an attempt to answer this, it doesn't break it down in that much depth. To me, it seems that consumerism has a clear link to socioeconomic class, and it can be at it's most insidious when poor people are lured into buying things they don't need and can't afford. This would have been a fascinating angle to look at it from, and I personally think the filmmakers missed a trick by omitting it.
My second main issue is the sincerity of the people involved in the film. It all started to sound a bit self-richeous and even hypocritical when you have people being filmed on their MacBooks or in their nice cars talking about living a "minimalist" lifestyle. In reality, I think this film is much more about conscious and balanced living rather than a radical form of minimalism. My issue is mainly with the framing of these lives as minimalist. Sure they might be more so than your average westerner, but as one man perfectly articulates in the movie, "a real minimalist would be a hermit, a recluse, a monk". He's right, they would be. After all, the lifestyle The Minimalists are promoting on their book tour is not radical, requires no real sacrifice of anything apart from excess possessions and is still inherently westernised, which I guess is why it is so attractive to people. That is not to discredit the value of such a way of life, but to call it minimalist feels more than a little pretentious, especially considering the money they were undoubtedly making in book sales and for the documentary itself.
My main issues with films like this nearly always come down to the lack of grounding and appropriate framing. What should be a concise synopsis on the merits of a quirky alternative lifestyle normally become a bit full of themselves and devolve into an exercise of hyperbole and preaching to the choir. That is my overarching problem with this documentary, the way it portrays these people's lives as better than our own, as something to aspire to, when in actual fact it is not much more than a form of neo-buddhism depicted as something profound. If the aim was to tackle the subject on a deeper level, it would have reached back into the roots of such ideas, in buddhism and other philosophies from around the world. I mean, this is hardly a new idea! As this didn't seem to be the intention, it would have been nice to see more of the practical aspect of converting to this way of living, such as the small spaces converted into quirky homes. This combined with the insights into the epidemic of overconsumption would have made for a modest manageable film, but I feel like too often it strayed into territory that it had no business being in, detracting from the other topics.
At the end of the day, you do not need to buy a book to become a "minimalist", nor is it necessarily the best way to live. This film provides a fairly strong case for such a lifestyle being something worth investigating, but I believe in people making up their own minds on what they want in life. For some it will be a simplification of their material lives, but for others it will involve embracing even greater complexity. It is far from a black and white question, it is completely subjective. I applaud the filmmakers for bringing up several very important issues that are only going to grow in relevance and impact as the 21st century rolls on, and I do agree in general that we have become lost in a vast storm of distractions, instant pleasures and pointless material goods that take away more than they give us. But we are also blessed with the power to choose our own destinies, and how we decide to express that is unique to each of us. Whether a minimalist of a maximalist, make the most of your life!
Overall: 55/100