The Greatest
Game Ever Played is a biopgraphical film about Francis Ouimet and his triumph
at the 1913 US Open where he defeated his golfing idol Harry Vardon in an epic
playoff. Adapted from Mark Frost’s 2002 book about the game, the film depicts
Ouimet’s honest upbringing in Boston, his work from a young age as a caddy, and
his father’s ambivalence towards the sport of golf for its elitist nature in the
early 1900’s.

The main
bulk of the film is spent focussing on the championship, and this is maybe
where it will lose those who aren’t golf fans. I was happy with how the
tournament action was shot and described though, it is a credit to Paxton than
he didn’t feel the need to make it too audience friendly yet still tense and
watchable for more casual golf fans. That being said, being so into golf, I can
clarify that the swings of almost every player were not very good. I realise
that players back then would have swung the club very differently to players
today, but we’re talking about Harry Vardon here, one of the greatest players
of all time. I liked the nods to Vardon’s famous grip though, perhaps his most
enduring legacy. The championship scenes were really entertaining, and the
final holes felt very suspenseful despite being predictable. Ouimet’s victory
was a cathartic and actually emotional moment. Seeing his father there in the
adoring crowd during the celebrations was genuinely moving because you
understood that his change of heart involved a lot of pain.
My main
issues with this film lie in the acting and script. I don’t think anyone gave
an outright bad performance, but there were only 1 or 2 that stood out and a
fair few missteps. Shia LaBeouf was only 19 when he took on this role, and for
the most part he does a pretty good job. It is nothing special, but he gave the
character a fair amount of scope and depth. It did feel quite one dimensional
at times though, like I knew how he was going to act in each scene. I didn’t
particularly feel the performances of Stephen Dillane as Vardon and Stephen
Marcus as Ted Ray. It felt like they relied too heavily on one particular persona,
the stiff upper lipped golfers who gave people piercing glances when they
wanted to convey an emotion. I would have liked Vardon to have had much more
dialogue so that I could have got to know him better. Peter Firth played the
eccentric newspaper magnate Lord Northcliffe and gave perhaps the best performance
in the movie. His pompous snobbery was as disgraceful and shocking as it should
have been, provided by the great dialogue he was given. The child actor who
played Francis’ caddy Eddie, Josh Flitter, did a reasonable job considering his
age, although he did often come off as very cartoonish. He did add some great
comic relief to the story, but I’m not sure he always fitted the tone of some
of the more serious scenes. All in all, it was a mixed bag on the acting front.
The script had both highs and lows, but with a great story to fall back on, it
didn’t detract too much from the film’s impact.
Despite
having a few issues with The Greatest Game Ever Played, I really enjoyed
watching it. It gave me a fascinating insight into the history of the game I
love so much. I cared about Francis and his struggle to overcome the harsh
prejudices of the sport in order to fulfil his dream to win a major. The movie
will definitely split opinion, which will have a lot to do with whether you
like golf and care about the characters. Even so, there is more to this story
than just a young boy winning a golf competition, so give it a fair chance.
Acting: 60
Narrative:
85
Visuals: 70
Music: N/A
Overall:
72/100